Forum SettingsEpisode Information
Forums
New
What did you think of this episode?
DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
Pages (2) « 1 [2]
Feb 28, 5:21 AM
Offline
Jun 2007
709
Hope Senku is fine with "minor" injury.
Xeno is too ambitious to "take over" the stone world
Feb 28, 6:19 AM
Offline
Jan 2021
239
Reply to MikuXLegend
One question will be

Will senku be okay?
@MikuXLegend they will use medusa i think
Feb 28, 6:49 AM
Offline
Aug 2023
28
If he's alive yes that's a good prediction
Feb 28, 7:28 AM

Offline
Feb 2016
1108
YOOO, FINALLY A GOOD FUCKING EPISODE
It had science, it had plot, it had tension, Senku is actually fucking scared, there were 0 jokes.
If only this entire series were always like that...
Sorry if my english is bad (っ˘▽˘)っ~~~
Btw, cry about it.

Feb 28, 10:54 AM

Offline
Mar 2010
56059
Holy dr. x really just doesn't give two shits no more.. thought he would be just a bit more rationale once he found out he knew senku... that he just didn't even blink a eye..

Behold of my awesomeness~
controversial and/or sensitive topics likely devolve into the same repetitive, derogatory, abusive, and harassing comments can no longer be posted.
But my feels.
Feb 28, 11:28 AM
Offline
Jul 2024
53
Holy Moly guacamoly. That was really some good stuff.
Feb 28, 4:55 PM

Offline
Jul 2013
2107
This show just loves to have some questionable writing, then follows it up with cool enough justification for it.

Like, Luna probably has single digit IQ if she doesn't realize that Senku is the real scientist after hearing his entire life story. Well, it doesn't matter anyway because Xeno knows immediately.

Or how Medusa ran out of juice at a very (in)convenient time after being in use for decades, but it has to because "5 meters 10 seconds" would've easily fixed any problem otherwise.
Feb 28, 5:44 PM

Offline
Dec 2013
15146
The shooting scene was intense! I love how Stanley used Luna's mistake to find Senku.

There's no way Senku is dead but he will probably be out of action for a while.
Feb 28, 9:09 PM
Offline
Feb 2024
4
The cliffhanger tho...
Mar 1, 4:35 AM

Offline
Jul 2015
12638
That was rather absurd.
Senku having a bright idea in the whim to create a bag full of non-Newtonian fluid in few seconds, predicting he is going to get shot and it successful blocking the bullet was rather unrealistic.

Mar 1, 8:13 AM
Offline
Feb 2021
1
Senku reaction is outstanding!
Mar 1, 5:28 PM

Offline
Mar 2014
24
Reply to JustMonaka
This show just loves to have some questionable writing, then follows it up with cool enough justification for it.

Like, Luna probably has single digit IQ if she doesn't realize that Senku is the real scientist after hearing his entire life story. Well, it doesn't matter anyway because Xeno knows immediately.

Or how Medusa ran out of juice at a very (in)convenient time after being in use for decades, but it has to because "5 meters 10 seconds" would've easily fixed any problem otherwise.
@JustMonaka she doesn’t speak nor understand Japanese. To be fair, the anime doesn't really highlight when they are speaking Japanese only and English only
Mar 1, 8:38 PM

Offline
Oct 2019
983
It was unfortunate they heavily retconned the story to make things far, far easier for Dr Xeno and his group, and greatly speed up their backstory.
After all the significance placed on the precise ratio of alcohol and nitric acid, during season 1, with Tsukasa willing to kill for the recipe in order to raise his army of goons, human statues were retconned to be easily revived with merely diluted nitric acid from bat poo...

That was how Senku was originally revived, but after exposure over centuries, not within a few minutes. Even in the previous episode it was mentioned nitric acid alone attacked the petrified birds extremely slowly, a few ions at the time; and yet now they can unpetrify humans within minutes.

A second ridiculous retcon was that claimed requirement to remain conscious during the entire time, which was never raised or hinted before. We know of only one case when someone pulled that off: Senku. But he did it to count time, not to ensure getting revived.

The (former) "magic liquid" has worked on anyone without fail before, so the "remaining conscious" bit was an unnecessary retcon.

As for Stanley's superhuman sniper skills, while a 3+ km sniper shot is possible, for obvious reasons it only works on stationary targets. Even if Stanley used a custom replica of an M2 Browning, with a .50 BMG caliber bullet (the largest bullet a sniper could use), which has a maximum range of 5+ km, at an assumed 3km 6 to 8 seconds would be required for the bullet to reach its target.

In 6 - 8 seconds Senku could run halfway along the ship. So if the target hears the shot, as Senku did, they can casually avoid it. The point of shooting from such a distance is not (just) bragging rights but a silent kill of a stationary target.

Furthermore I doubt even a .50 BMG bullet would have enough energy to pierce through Perseus' thick wooden hull at such a huge distance. Up to a couple of km it could do it, but at what looked like 3 km? Nope, no way...

Nitpicking aside (😆) it was disappointing Dr Xeno still gave the kill order at the end against his old student.
He no longer sees Senku as a student but as a rival, an obstacle to his world domination plans.
A classic sociopath drunk on a power trip...
SharpedonMar 1, 9:05 PM
Mar 1, 10:33 PM
Offline
Jul 2017
1
I love that this anime pretty much uses everything I've ever learnt about science... and even more, when I saw Senku grabbing the starch and then adding water I went "oh shit, non-newtonian fluid as body armor!" and the bullet didn't go through the boat with the original shape, only shrapnel managed to go through, the attention to detail is always great!
Mar 1, 10:54 PM
Offline
Jul 2024
15
Reply to BladeX05
Did we really needed that mumbo-jumbo with his voice to determine Senkus height and shit? Couldn't he just said that his hair looks like a leek? 😂
@BladeX05
BladeX05 said:
Couldn't he just said that his hair looks like a leek?

His hairstyle is probably a design choice for the audience rather than something that is actually present in universe. Think how quintessential quintuplets uses hair color to differentiate between them.
Mar 1, 10:58 PM
Offline
Jul 2024
15
Reply to PettankoLover
How did xeno know senku was going to revive too?? what a stretch
@PettankoLover
PettankoLover said:
How did xeno know senku was going to revive too?? what a stretch

Did you forget about Luna relaying "Senku" to him?
Simple train of logic goes:
"Senku" and high rate of scientific advancement means a scientist named Senku, oh wait it's that guy
Mar 1, 11:05 PM
Offline
Jul 2024
15
Reply to Sharpedon
It was unfortunate they heavily retconned the story to make things far, far easier for Dr Xeno and his group, and greatly speed up their backstory.
After all the significance placed on the precise ratio of alcohol and nitric acid, during season 1, with Tsukasa willing to kill for the recipe in order to raise his army of goons, human statues were retconned to be easily revived with merely diluted nitric acid from bat poo...

That was how Senku was originally revived, but after exposure over centuries, not within a few minutes. Even in the previous episode it was mentioned nitric acid alone attacked the petrified birds extremely slowly, a few ions at the time; and yet now they can unpetrify humans within minutes.

A second ridiculous retcon was that claimed requirement to remain conscious during the entire time, which was never raised or hinted before. We know of only one case when someone pulled that off: Senku. But he did it to count time, not to ensure getting revived.

The (former) "magic liquid" has worked on anyone without fail before, so the "remaining conscious" bit was an unnecessary retcon.

As for Stanley's superhuman sniper skills, while a 3+ km sniper shot is possible, for obvious reasons it only works on stationary targets. Even if Stanley used a custom replica of an M2 Browning, with a .50 BMG caliber bullet (the largest bullet a sniper could use), which has a maximum range of 5+ km, at an assumed 3km 6 to 8 seconds would be required for the bullet to reach its target.

In 6 - 8 seconds Senku could run halfway along the ship. So if the target hears the shot, as Senku did, they can casually avoid it. The point of shooting from such a distance is not (just) bragging rights but a silent kill of a stationary target.

Furthermore I doubt even a .50 BMG bullet would have enough energy to pierce through Perseus' thick wooden hull at such a huge distance. Up to a couple of km it could do it, but at what looked like 3 km? Nope, no way...

Nitpicking aside (😆) it was disappointing Dr Xeno still gave the kill order at the end against his old student.
He no longer sees Senku as a student but as a rival, an obstacle to his world domination plans.
A classic sociopath drunk on a power trip...
Sharpedon said:
It was unfortunate they heavily retconned the story to make things far, far easier for Dr Xeno and his group, and greatly speed up their backstory.
After all the significance placed on the precise ratio of alcohol and nitric acid, during season 1, with Tsukasa willing to kill for the recipe in order to raise his army of goons, human statues were retconned to be easily revived with merely diluted nitric acid from bat poo...

That was how Senku was originally revived, but after exposure over centuries, not within a few minutes. Even in the previous episode it was mentioned nitric acid alone attacked the petrified birds extremely slowly, a few ions at the time; and yet now they can unpetrify humans within minutes.

A second ridiculous retcon was that claimed requirement to remain conscious during the entire time, which was never raised or hinted before. We know of only one case when someone pulled that off: Senku. But he did it to count time, not to ensure getting revived.

The (former) "magic liquid" has worked on anyone without fail before, so the "remaining conscious" bit was an unnecessary retcon.

As for Stanley's superhuman sniper skills, while a 3+ km sniper shot is possible, for obvious reasons it only works on stationary targets. Even if Stanley used a custom replica of an M2 Browning, with a .50 BMG caliber bullet (the largest bullet a sniper could use), which has a maximum range of 5+ km, at an assumed 3km 6 to 8 seconds would be required for the bullet to reach its target.

In 6 - 8 seconds Senku could run halfway along the ship. So if the target hears the shot, as Senku did, they can casually avoid it. The point of shooting from such a distance is not (just) bragging rights but a silent kill of a stationary target.

Furthermore I doubt even a .50 BMG bullet would have enough energy to pierce through Perseus' thick wooden hull at such a huge distance. Up to a couple of km it could do it, but at what looked like 3 km? Nope, no way...

Nitpicking aside (😆) it was disappointing Dr Xeno still gave the kill order at the end against his old student.
He no longer sees Senku as a student but as a rival, an obstacle to his world domination plans.
A classic sociopath drunk on a power trip...


They were revived by Nitric Acid and not Nital Etch because they stayed conscious.

Staying conscious was a requirement to bring revived by Nitric Acid, Nital Etch can revive anyone.

The "Magic Liquid" is something Xeno's group never had, hence why they don't have very many people.

He couldn't run halfway across the ship after the shot, he ran before it. 6-8 seconds to run doesn't matter and is completely wrong.

A lot of these "retcons" are debunked by the fact that Nitric Acid and Nital Etch are different, where Senku could revive everyone because he had Nital Etch, but Xeno could only revive people who stayed conscious because he only had Nitric Acid and not Nital Etch.
Mar 2, 12:22 PM

Offline
Nov 2016
199
Reply to snaukball
@PettankoLover
PettankoLover said:
How did xeno know senku was going to revive too?? what a stretch

Did you forget about Luna relaying "Senku" to him?
Simple train of logic goes:
"Senku" and high rate of scientific advancement means a scientist named Senku, oh wait it's that guy
@snaukball I meant after the stone rays
Mar 2, 2:45 PM
Offline
Nov 2020
87
Really good, exciting episode. Xeno's definitely the most interesting adversary the Kingdom of Science faced so far. His dynamic with Senku is just so cool to watch.
Mar 3, 3:44 AM

Offline
Sep 2022
12
The end of this episode was genuisely so exciting! The wait for Stan's shoot and the sudden urgency felt by Senku and his peers gave an amazing payoff

Now I just want to see next episode

Mar 3, 6:30 AM
Offline
Jul 2024
15
Reply to PettankoLover
@snaukball I meant after the stone rays
@PettankoLover Lucky guess maybe? It could just be that he knows Senku is like him in that they both love science, so that might justify it?
Mar 3, 6:42 PM
Offline
Jul 2020
1
Holy CRAP I need more Dr. Stone immediatly.

By far one of the most tensest moments in the anime, I loved every second of it.

Cant wait for more.
Mar 3, 9:23 PM

Offline
Feb 2021
3086
Seems like Senku still got hurt because of the penetration.
- Mal-Badge -

Level 25
Ranked 1135
Last update : 27.02.2022 at 05:50

My Candies :


I'm level on mal-badges. View my badges.



Mar 5, 11:53 AM

Offline
Sep 2011
176
poor xeno. so much in getting stanley to quit smoking in the new world lol
Mar 5, 4:32 PM

Offline
Jul 2016
8901
Okay. Just how many years did Xeno have to build and develop his Science Kingdom? Because there is no way he and Senkuu depetrified at the same time. Xeno should have depetrified way before Senkuu.

And why didn't Xeno just tell Stanley to shoot the dude whose hairstyle looks like a mutant daikon? What the hell was all that with him materializing recordings of Senkuu's voice out of thin air lmao?

Man, the development of this arc sure is obliterating the very little suspension of disbelief I had for this show.
Mar 5, 11:57 PM
🥊 CHAMPION 🥊

Offline
Apr 2016
24684
A scientist who prefers to attack rather than engage in dialogue is not a scientist, he is a murderer.
kekeke
Mar 6, 9:37 AM
Offline
Nov 2022
1221
Bro, it feels really cool to see something that appears in this series and understand it, like non-Newtonian liquid.
Mar 13, 9:38 AM

Offline
Aug 2018
458
This episode was intense. It's understandable why Luna was unable to point out to Taiju, since having the blood of someone on your hands is just impossible to bear.

I really doubt that Senku was severely injured by that shot at the end, probably one of the fragments scratched his arm or something. It's also realistic they showed that the bullet actually was not a single bullet, but it turned into many small pieces, because bullets work like that.
Mar 13, 9:47 AM

Offline
Aug 2018
458
Reply to MewsicMagic
@Softhenic03 He did hesitate a bit though. In his own way he thought very logically through the benefits and issues that would arise with joining forces with Senku and even showed some emotional attachment to knowing who he is. Ultimately he decided that preventing Senku from getting ahead of him was the best course of action.

Him and Senku are very similar in the sense that they decide and do things based on logic, and logically it just seemed to best course of action to him.
MewsicMagic said:
Him and Senku are very similar in the sense that they decide and do things based on logic, and logically it just seemed to best course of action to him.


But Senku would never kill someone it that were to be the best course of action for him. The anime already showed quite many times that Senku is more soft that what he's shown to be.

Overall, I was also disappointed that he chose to shoot Senku, especially because they already used that troop before with Tsukasa, and we all know how that went.

BladeX05 said:
Did we really needed that mumbo-jumbo with his voice to determine Senkus height and shit?


Exactly, are those calculations even possible? Like, I suppose they could be done, but it would give a very uncertain height. Not only that, from where did Xeno have Senku's voice recorded? It was already made clear in the anime that they weren't able to recover any record from the past (example with the Lilian songs). It just kinda feels they forgot about that.
Mar 13, 12:17 PM

Offline
Dec 2023
136
Reply to PokefanPT
MewsicMagic said:
Him and Senku are very similar in the sense that they decide and do things based on logic, and logically it just seemed to best course of action to him.


But Senku would never kill someone it that were to be the best course of action for him. The anime already showed quite many times that Senku is more soft that what he's shown to be.

Overall, I was also disappointed that he chose to shoot Senku, especially because they already used that troop before with Tsukasa, and we all know how that went.

BladeX05 said:
Did we really needed that mumbo-jumbo with his voice to determine Senkus height and shit?


Exactly, are those calculations even possible? Like, I suppose they could be done, but it would give a very uncertain height. Not only that, from where did Xeno have Senku's voice recorded? It was already made clear in the anime that they weren't able to recover any record from the past (example with the Lilian songs). It just kinda feels they forgot about that.
@PokefanPT I've heard people that are 5,2 with crazy deep voices, and people that are 6,2 with average voices, the answer is probably not. Those calculations would give a LOT of room for error, so realistically they're "possible" but realistically they're not very useful. I would just guess and say probably 5,6 to 6 foot since you can't get much better than that without more to go on.

Also the voice he got was from the radio transmission which had a split second of him speaking.
Yesterday, 8:19 AM

Offline
Aug 2022
3347
He could've just gone below the deck. Or on the other side of the ship. Lol.
Pages (2) « 1 [2]

More topics from this board

Poll: » Dr. Stone: Science Future Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 )

Stark700 - Mar 13

54 by SanchezCordero »»
50 minutes ago

Poll: » Dr. Stone: Science Future Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 )

Stark700 - Mar 6

82 by Leonil_1ppo »»
10 hours ago

» Anime pacing

Jollyne7 - Mar 13

8 by Dan_ALves »»
Yesterday, 2:56 PM

Poll: » Dr. Stone: Science Future Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 )

Stark700 - Jan 16

73 by Khashishi »»
Mar 12, 4:07 PM

Poll: » Dr. Stone: Science Future Episode 7 Discussion ( 1 2 )

Stark700 - Feb 20

80 by PokefanPT »»
Mar 7, 4:19 PM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login